Hey everyone,
When I came into the office this morning to do some more preparation for our upcoming relational aesthetics study group, Michael slipped me this fascinating article.
If you're feeling relationally inspired, check it out on line or there is also a hard copy available in the Dancemakers office. I like it because while it's very much on topic, it was written by architects who approach the topic with different preoccupations and curiousities than I do and venture into a whole other set of practical applications.
It comes from a research conference called "The Museum of Conflict - Art as Political Strategy in Post-Communist Europe" which focused on two major questions:
How does the institutional museum reflect ways in which contemporary art is used as a representation of political change?
Can art take over the location of power, being 'a symbol of openness and democracy?'
Enjoy!
Thursday, November 26, 2009
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Coming up...Thinking Out Loud 3
(Kari Pederson)
It's about that time again...we are looking forward to our third Thinking Out Loud this December 1st at 6:30. Whether you have attended a previous TOL event or if this will be your first we wold love to have you join us for an evening of interesting and relaxed conversation, snacks and refreshments at Dancemakers. Tell your friends, lovers, colleagues and teachers - everyone is welcome.
In our upcoming TOL we will be contemplating the changing relationships between spectator, artist and participant through these articles:
"Relational Form" by Nicolas Bourriaud (1998) (with a particular focus on the section titled 'Artwork As Social Interstice'
"The Emancipated Spectator" by Jacques Ranciere (2004)
"The Social Turn: Collaboration and Its Discontents" by Claire Bishop (2006)
(click the title for a pdf or find a hardcopy, and a photocopier, in the Dancemakers office)
We hope to see you there. Please RSVP and join us at the Dancermakers’ Centre for Creation on December 1st at 6:30.
Bring your curiosity, openness, some spare change for drinks and anyone you know who might be interested in snacks and stimulating conversation.
It's about that time again...we are looking forward to our third Thinking Out Loud this December 1st at 6:30. Whether you have attended a previous TOL event or if this will be your first we wold love to have you join us for an evening of interesting and relaxed conversation, snacks and refreshments at Dancemakers. Tell your friends, lovers, colleagues and teachers - everyone is welcome.
In our upcoming TOL we will be contemplating the changing relationships between spectator, artist and participant through these articles:
"Relational Form" by Nicolas Bourriaud (1998) (with a particular focus on the section titled 'Artwork As Social Interstice'
"The Emancipated Spectator" by Jacques Ranciere (2004)
"The Social Turn: Collaboration and Its Discontents" by Claire Bishop (2006)
(click the title for a pdf or find a hardcopy, and a photocopier, in the Dancemakers office)
We hope to see you there. Please RSVP and join us at the Dancermakers’ Centre for Creation on December 1st at 6:30.
Bring your curiosity, openness, some spare change for drinks and anyone you know who might be interested in snacks and stimulating conversation.
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Long-awaited-eagerly-anticipated Study Group #2 Notes
Things have been buzzing here at Dancemakers, but finally, for your perusal, here are the notes Kari and I compiled from our awesome second Thinking Out Loud session, all about the ideas of contemporariness, reconstruction, and modernism.
Notes from Thinking Out Loud #2 - Monday, October 19, 2009
Here are our notes from the last TOL! Dancemakers has been very busy lately and we have been discussing new articles for next TOL, which falls on December 1st. We will post them soon - but for now, see below:
“What is the Contemporary?” – Giorgio Agamben
“How Modern Is Modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction”
- André Lepecki
“Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance” - a short essay from the Goethe-Institute website
What connections to The Act of Study (TOL’s first article by Paulo Freire) arose while reading this article?
- Being Agamben’s “contemporary” is like being what Freire calls a subject (an ideal learner). It is not static but a process.
Using Freire’s concept of a flash idea, what flashed while reading “What Is Contemporary?”
- I thought about how I’ve come to where I am and how I can use others’ work as a filtration system to learn about where I am and what is contemporary to me. For instance I prefer contemporary work but it’s lineage is not forgotten. It’s like a line of evolution that you can cut into. Peggy Baker is an example of this: I’m not a fan of her work but I’m a fan of her student’s work.
- if I prefer the contemporary, why would I want to read the “pre _____” if there is a “post _____”,? For instance, why learn about modernism if we are post-modern?
Thoughts on the article’s form:
- Elitist or academic
- Poetic and hard to grasp.
- Inspiring but daunting – if I do what he is asking of me I can’t do things like buy my groceries
- “Contemporary” as an idealism
- A higher call to action – like a manifesto to become more “contemporary” (by Agamben’s definition)
Notes from Thinking Out Loud #2 - Monday, October 19, 2009
Here are our notes from the last TOL! Dancemakers has been very busy lately and we have been discussing new articles for next TOL, which falls on December 1st. We will post them soon - but for now, see below:
“What is the Contemporary?” – Giorgio Agamben
“How Modern Is Modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction”
- André Lepecki
“Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance” - a short essay from the Goethe-Institute website
-
“What Is Contemporary?”
What connections to The Act of Study (TOL’s first article by Paulo Freire) arose while reading this article?
- Being Agamben’s “contemporary” is like being what Freire calls a subject (an ideal learner). It is not static but a process.
Using Freire’s concept of a flash idea, what flashed while reading “What Is Contemporary?”
- I thought about how I’ve come to where I am and how I can use others’ work as a filtration system to learn about where I am and what is contemporary to me. For instance I prefer contemporary work but it’s lineage is not forgotten. It’s like a line of evolution that you can cut into. Peggy Baker is an example of this: I’m not a fan of her work but I’m a fan of her student’s work.
- if I prefer the contemporary, why would I want to read the “pre _____” if there is a “post _____”,? For instance, why learn about modernism if we are post-modern?
Thoughts on the article’s form:
- Elitist or academic
- Poetic and hard to grasp.
- Inspiring but daunting – if I do what he is asking of me I can’t do things like buy my groceries
- “Contemporary” as an idealism
- A higher call to action – like a manifesto to become more “contemporary” (by Agamben’s definition)
Thursday, October 15, 2009
Oct 19 update
(Jacob Zimmer)
Looking forward to the second study group on Monday.
The last one was great - a set of wonderful but radically incomplete notes are posted below - please comment, add, jump off from etc...
Rereading the What is the contemporary? article – I want to acknowledge that it’s pretty dense and there is a lot of language that requires second (or more) readings and liberal use of a dictionary. But this excites me. And it excites me in relationship to last weeks reading of The Act of Study. I’ve been thinking about marking the ideas or sentences that flash or pop out to me and connect with my preoccupations. We’ll work through the ideas and writing together through our own responses, a process I’m looking forward to. So, no fear, we're in it together.
I also wanted to link to another article that, I think, addresses some of the same issues with an explicit tie in to practice, specifically Martha Graham. We’ll focus on What is the contemporary? But the other two will be a tie in to dance practice.
To access the new article, just click here: How modern is modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction. An Essay by André Lepecki about the Martha Graham Retrospective. As always, this new article is available in hard copy at the Dancemakers office.
We’ll still be looking at Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance: a short essay/website from the Goethe-Institut website.
Your RSVP’s and thoughts are more than welcome.
Looking forward to the second study group on Monday.
The last one was great - a set of wonderful but radically incomplete notes are posted below - please comment, add, jump off from etc...
Rereading the What is the contemporary? article – I want to acknowledge that it’s pretty dense and there is a lot of language that requires second (or more) readings and liberal use of a dictionary. But this excites me. And it excites me in relationship to last weeks reading of The Act of Study. I’ve been thinking about marking the ideas or sentences that flash or pop out to me and connect with my preoccupations. We’ll work through the ideas and writing together through our own responses, a process I’m looking forward to. So, no fear, we're in it together.
I also wanted to link to another article that, I think, addresses some of the same issues with an explicit tie in to practice, specifically Martha Graham. We’ll focus on What is the contemporary? But the other two will be a tie in to dance practice.
To access the new article, just click here: How modern is modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction. An Essay by André Lepecki about the Martha Graham Retrospective. As always, this new article is available in hard copy at the Dancemakers office.
We’ll still be looking at Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance: a short essay/website from the Goethe-Institut website.
Your RSVP’s and thoughts are more than welcome.
Tuesday, October 13, 2009
Next Thinking Out Loud October 19
Our inaugural Thinking Out Loud – the Study Group session last Tuesday was fantastic. Thanks to everyone who came.
If you weren't there, we hope you can make it out to the next one, so we can share ideas and pretzels with you, too.
All you need to do is RSVP and show up (with some spare change for a beer or a glass of wine). Feel free to bring some dinner with you to eat during our discussion, or on the break we promise we will take around 7:45pm
The next meeting will take place on Monday October 19th at 6:30pm. We will once again be gathering in the studio at Dancermakers’ Centre for Creation (click here for a map/directions) on the 3rd floor.
We will be discussing Giorgio Agamben article What is the contemporary? which can be found on the a.aaaarg.org website by clicking here (you will need to register for the website in order to access the pdf – do it.)
We’ll also look at Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance: a short essay/website from the Goethe-Institut website.
and How modern is modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction. An Essay by André Lepecki about the Martha Graham Retrospective
More...
Alternatively, swing by the Dancemakers office if you’d rather pick up a hard copy of both articles.
It’s a bit more challenging read – but we think worth it and good for conversation.
Although this next meeting is on a Monday, future dates for Thinking Out Loud are all Tuesdays:
December 1, January 5, February 2, March 2, March 30, and April 27.
Please continue to spread the word to friends, colleagues, teachers, and so on, if you think this might tickle their fancy.
We look forward to another stimulating exchange!
Jacob, Megan, Kari and Leora
Dancemakers & The Dance Current
If you weren't there, we hope you can make it out to the next one, so we can share ideas and pretzels with you, too.
All you need to do is RSVP and show up (with some spare change for a beer or a glass of wine). Feel free to bring some dinner with you to eat during our discussion, or on the break we promise we will take around 7:45pm
The next meeting will take place on Monday October 19th at 6:30pm. We will once again be gathering in the studio at Dancermakers’ Centre for Creation (click here for a map/directions) on the 3rd floor.
We will be discussing Giorgio Agamben article What is the contemporary? which can be found on the a.aaaarg.org website by clicking here (you will need to register for the website in order to access the pdf – do it.)
We’ll also look at Reconstructing Dance: Taking an Active Interest in the Legacy of Dance: a short essay/website from the Goethe-Institut website.
and How modern is modernism? The Relevance of Reconstruction. An Essay by André Lepecki about the Martha Graham Retrospective
More...
Alternatively, swing by the Dancemakers office if you’d rather pick up a hard copy of both articles.
It’s a bit more challenging read – but we think worth it and good for conversation.
Although this next meeting is on a Monday, future dates for Thinking Out Loud are all Tuesdays:
December 1, January 5, February 2, March 2, March 30, and April 27.
Please continue to spread the word to friends, colleagues, teachers, and so on, if you think this might tickle their fancy.
We look forward to another stimulating exchange!
Jacob, Megan, Kari and Leora
Dancemakers & The Dance Current
Notes from the first Thinking Out Loud!
(by Kari Pederson)
An eclectic and insightful group met on September 29th for the first of the Thinking Out Loud series. We had an interesting conversation rooted in Paulo Freire's "The Act of Study" from his book The politics of education: culture, power and liberation (1985). I've taken the liberty of posting Leora's notes from the evening (thanks Leora!). The notes are great and I've added links to help to fill in some blanks for those of you who weren't able to make the first TOL. It was an excellent start to the series and I think we would all agree that Freire's article will continue to inform our creative and critical learning process!
Thinking Out Loud: The Study Group - Notes - September 29, 2009
how to bring Freire’s concept of learning to every day artistic and non-artistic practices?
article written as a manifesto. makes you want to read on. what is a manifesto? call to action? set of beliefs articulated with conviction?
empty space ... is a problem in dance training that there is no room for elevation beyond empirical? (empirical = derived from experiment, observation, rather than theory)
mastery = knowledge + silence/personal ownership?
(as opposed to consuming + regurgitating)
More...
bibliographies. idea of placing articles, ideas, works in socio-politico-historical context by reading bibliography, understanding what situates author in his/her life at time of writing.
dialectical relationship: is tension in dialogue between reader/author where learning occurs?
do we have a responsibility to contextualize?
to whom?
artist biographies vs. program notes
what are the artists reading/doing that brought them to this point?
can this information replace “contextualizing” of descriptive writing about piece?
people’s different habits around reading programs before/after seeing work.
do some forms of art (text-based theatre) limit our potential to flash because they keep us so busy (with the words for example), and involved in the world onstage?
what are the rituals around form (dance class structure, “uniforms”, etc)?
how does this affect learning?
what happens when you remove the ritual of form (doing a tendu on top of a mountain at sunrise by yourself instead of in dance class at the barre wearing a leotard)?
are audiences consuming art mindlessly? what can artists demand from audiences?
how to cultivate a curious audience?
curiosity vs. criticality. indulging in/addressing one’s own preoccupations vs. discovering one’s thoughts on author’s thinking?
(critical: “characterized by careful, exact evaluation and judgment”, “marked by a tendency to find and call attention to errors and flaws”)
flashes as having value when we return with them to author’s total thinking?
(as opposed to daydreaming)
definition of “political” – is every work political, whether or not its aware of its politics? i.e. are politics inherently imbedded in every expression, or does a work need to explicitly being trying to rebel/revolt/make heard a silenced voice in order to be political?
is So You Think You Can Dance political?
are politics of a work least obvious to you when they are in line with the voice of your community?
Jacques Ranciere (The Emancipated Spectator (2004), The Ignorant Schoolmaster: Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation (1991))
keep coming back to quote on pg. 2:
“seriously studying a text calls for an analysis of the study of the one who, through studying, wrote it” - Paulo Freire
how do you create a 50% show, where audience meets you halfway? (reference to Jerome Bell)
is there value in sitting with and observing discomfort, lack of interest in a piece, etc? is the learning located in discovering what does/doesn’t engage you and what that might tell you about yourself as a subject-learner?
where in learning does space fit in?
silence?
re-envisioning of the class structure and pedagogy (ritualized hierarchy as oppressive)?
teacher as catalyst to thinking about old things new ways (gateway to the flashes), as learner you can receive it passively or actively
agency.
communication as communing.
Richard Pochinko's clown concept: circle around performer, circle around audience, circle in the middle where they meet is where performance happens. this “inter-subjective” space as where “subject learning” happens?
An eclectic and insightful group met on September 29th for the first of the Thinking Out Loud series. We had an interesting conversation rooted in Paulo Freire's "The Act of Study" from his book The politics of education: culture, power and liberation (1985). I've taken the liberty of posting Leora's notes from the evening (thanks Leora!). The notes are great and I've added links to help to fill in some blanks for those of you who weren't able to make the first TOL. It was an excellent start to the series and I think we would all agree that Freire's article will continue to inform our creative and critical learning process!
Thinking Out Loud: The Study Group - Notes - September 29, 2009
how to bring Freire’s concept of learning to every day artistic and non-artistic practices?
article written as a manifesto. makes you want to read on. what is a manifesto? call to action? set of beliefs articulated with conviction?
empty space ... is a problem in dance training that there is no room for elevation beyond empirical? (empirical = derived from experiment, observation, rather than theory)
mastery = knowledge + silence/personal ownership?
(as opposed to consuming + regurgitating)
More...
bibliographies. idea of placing articles, ideas, works in socio-politico-historical context by reading bibliography, understanding what situates author in his/her life at time of writing.
dialectical relationship: is tension in dialogue between reader/author where learning occurs?
do we have a responsibility to contextualize?
to whom?
artist biographies vs. program notes
what are the artists reading/doing that brought them to this point?
can this information replace “contextualizing” of descriptive writing about piece?
people’s different habits around reading programs before/after seeing work.
do some forms of art (text-based theatre) limit our potential to flash because they keep us so busy (with the words for example), and involved in the world onstage?
what are the rituals around form (dance class structure, “uniforms”, etc)?
how does this affect learning?
what happens when you remove the ritual of form (doing a tendu on top of a mountain at sunrise by yourself instead of in dance class at the barre wearing a leotard)?
are audiences consuming art mindlessly? what can artists demand from audiences?
how to cultivate a curious audience?
curiosity vs. criticality. indulging in/addressing one’s own preoccupations vs. discovering one’s thoughts on author’s thinking?
(critical: “characterized by careful, exact evaluation and judgment”, “marked by a tendency to find and call attention to errors and flaws”)
flashes as having value when we return with them to author’s total thinking?
(as opposed to daydreaming)
definition of “political” – is every work political, whether or not its aware of its politics? i.e. are politics inherently imbedded in every expression, or does a work need to explicitly being trying to rebel/revolt/make heard a silenced voice in order to be political?
is So You Think You Can Dance political?
are politics of a work least obvious to you when they are in line with the voice of your community?
Jacques Ranciere (The Emancipated Spectator (2004), The Ignorant Schoolmaster: Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation (1991))
keep coming back to quote on pg. 2:
“seriously studying a text calls for an analysis of the study of the one who, through studying, wrote it” - Paulo Freire
how do you create a 50% show, where audience meets you halfway? (reference to Jerome Bell)
is there value in sitting with and observing discomfort, lack of interest in a piece, etc? is the learning located in discovering what does/doesn’t engage you and what that might tell you about yourself as a subject-learner?
where in learning does space fit in?
silence?
re-envisioning of the class structure and pedagogy (ritualized hierarchy as oppressive)?
teacher as catalyst to thinking about old things new ways (gateway to the flashes), as learner you can receive it passively or actively
agency.
communication as communing.
Richard Pochinko's clown concept: circle around performer, circle around audience, circle in the middle where they meet is where performance happens. this “inter-subjective” space as where “subject learning” happens?
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
and then ...
As a result of the symposium and the roundtable discussion, Jacob Zimmer (dramaturge and animateur at Dancemakers) and Megan Andrews (publisher/founding editor of The Dance Current) began working together to develop Jacob's study group concept. Thinking Out Loud is the collaborative initiative that resulted.
It's an experiment.
We meet monthly (we being a small and fluctuating group of interested artists and arts professionals from across disciplines, practices and generations) to discuss an article or two that we circulate in advance of the meeting. Jacob and Megan facilitate the discussion, with the help of Dancemakers' interns Kari Pederson and Leora Morris. Participants help shape the discussion and suggest readings. Following the meetings, we'll post some reflections here and anyone is welcome to comment.
It's an experiment.
We meet monthly (we being a small and fluctuating group of interested artists and arts professionals from across disciplines, practices and generations) to discuss an article or two that we circulate in advance of the meeting. Jacob and Megan facilitate the discussion, with the help of Dancemakers' interns Kari Pederson and Leora Morris. Participants help shape the discussion and suggest readings. Following the meetings, we'll post some reflections here and anyone is welcome to comment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)